A critical analysis of basic income experiments for researchers, policymakers, and citizens. Propositional defeasible logic has linear complexity. The work reported here introduces defeasible logic programming delp, a formalism that combines results of logic programming and defeasible. But you can follow any of the programming books and there you will get better logic. Popular logic programming books showing of 30 programming in prolog. Embedding defeasible logic into logic programming article pdf available in theory and practice of logic programming 66. Download handbook of defeasible reasoning and uncertainty. Download a defeasible logic programmingbased framework. Defeasible logic considered in the paper follows the presentation of d. Pdf compilation techniques for defeasible logic programs. This webpage provides a web service for defeasible logic programming delp. An argumentative approach article pdf available in theory and practice of logic programming 42 january 2 with 127 reads how we measure reads.
Oct 01, 2001 in order to do this, an ldsbased logical framework for defeasible argumentation called lds. The work reported here introduces defeasible logic programming delp, a formalism that combines results of logic programming and defeasible argumentation. In addition, defeasible reasoning can be used to illuminate moral and legal dilemmas, cases in which general rules come into conflict see horty 1994, 2003. Pdf embedding defeasible logic into logic programming. In this paper we will show how a defeasible logic programming approach with an underlying. Defeasible logic is a rulebased nonmonotonic logic, with both strict and defeasible rules, and a priority relation on rules. Handbook of defeasible reasoning and uncertainty management. A defeasible logic programmingbased framework to support. Defeasible logic programming is a newly developed extension to conventional logic programming that captures some aspects of commonsense reasoning hard to model within the classical approach.
We often reach conclusions partially on the basis that we do not have evidence that the conclusion is false. Jan 30, 2018 the following list is reproduced from frequently asked questions at comp. In defeasible logic, there are three different types of propositions. In proceedings of the australian conference information systems, pages 2029, 1999. Dlp extends conventional logic programming, capturing common sense reasoning features, and providing a knowledge representation language for defeasible argumentation. Defeasible logic programming, or delp for short, provides a computational reasoning system that uses an argumentation engine to obtain. Defeasible logic versus logic programming without negation. Delp provides the possibility of representing information in the form of weak rules in a declarative manner, and a defeasible argumentation inference mechanism for warranting the entailed conclusions. The resulting approach is suitable for representing agents knowledge and for providing an argumentation based reasoning mechanism to agents. Handbook of logic in artificial intelligence and logic. Find the top 100 most popular items in amazon books best sellers. Defeasible logic, and sceptical logic programming without negation as failure lpwnf. Publications on defeasible logic grigoris antoniou, david billington, guido governatori, and michael j.
Defeasible logic is a nonmonotonic logic proposed by donald nute to formalize defeasible reasoning. In this paper we compare the expressive power of two approaches in this family of logics. This book reports on the development and validation framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications springer theses naeem khalid janjua free author. This contrasts markedly with most other propositional nonmonotonic logics, in which inference is intractable. Inspired by legal reasoning, this paper presents a semantics and proof theory of a system for defeasible argumentation. In other words, defeasible reasoning produces a contingent statement or claim. Part of the lecture notes in computer science book series lncs, volume 6645. The work reported here introduces defeasible logic programming delp, a formalism that combines results of logic programming. A system, based on defeasible reasoning and specifically designed for the semantic web environment, was also presented in this work. Adaptive logics for defeasible reasoning ebook by christian. Finally, it starts developing the logic of purely normative and of factregarding normative defeasible reasoning, points to the difficulties of completing the logic of the factregarding side, but reaches the initial aim of accounting for the defeasible nature of the practical syllogism. Defeasible logic is a nonmonotonic logic proposed by donald nute to formalize defeasible. A critical appraisal of germanys thermal retrofit policy. Pdf an application of defeasible logic programming to decision.
Defeasible reasoning is a useful tool when many facts about a situation are unknown. Defeasibility is found in literatures that are concerned with argument and the process of argument, or heuristic reasoning. Nominated as an a defeasible logic programmingbased. Nonmonotonicity in logic is a symptom that may have many causes. What are the best books for improving programming logic. The european commission and the management of eu structural funds in germany. Relevant to philosophy, law, management, and artificial intelligence, these papers explore the applicability of nonmonotonic or defeasible logic to normative reasoning. Delp provides the possibility of representing information in the form of weak rules in a declarative manner, and a defeasible argumentation inference mechanism for warranting the entailed. In contrast to this, in normal logic programming nlp, there is only one kind. It is based on the concept of a derivation or proof in d f,r. The system is called vdrdevice 1 and it comprises a visual integrated development environment for developing and deploying defeasible logic rule bases. Defeasible logic programming, or delp for short, provides a computational reasoning system that uses an argumentation engine to obtain answers from a knowledge base represented using a logic programming language extended with defeasible rules that stem from the work reported in simari and simari and loui. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. Abstract inspired by legal reasoning, this paper presents a semantics and proof theory of a system for defeasible argumentation.
Defeasible logic programming an argumentative approach 97 knowledge. This book presents adaptive logics as an intuitive and powerful framework for modeling defeasible reasoning. It usually occurs when a rule is given, but there may be specific exceptions to the rule, or subclasses that are subject to a different rule. Defeasible reasoning stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.
Defeasible logic, originally created by donald nute with a particular concern about efficiency and implementation, is a simple and efficient rule based nonmonotonic formalism. Defeasible reasoning is a particular kind of nondemonstrative reasoning, where the reasoning does not produce a full, complete, or final demonstration of a claim, i. Linked bibliography for the sep article defeasible. Of course, it would be best if we could have a probabilistic logic, where every statement has an attached probability. Thus dlp extends conventional logic programming, capturing common sense reasoning features, and also provides a knowledge representation language for defeasible argumentation. Embedding defeasible logic into logic programming delab. In particular, they allow a simple treatment of defeasible reasoning, which is essential for being able to capture many forms of commonsense policies and specifications. Defeasible reasoning is a simple but efficient approach to nonmonotonic reasoning that has recently attracted considerable interest and that has found various. Although technical in nature the book contains sections that outline basic issues by means of intuitive and simple. The proposed methodology is unique in providing a solution for representing incomplete andor contradictory information coming from different sources, and reasoning with it. Defeasible logic can enable general rules to play an indispensable role despite the reasons holism that dancy has uncovered. Over the year the logic has been developed and extended, and several variants have been proposed.
Algorithms for uncertainty and defeasible reasoning. Arguments are expressed in a logic programming language with both weak and strong negation, conflicts between arguments are decided with the help of priorities on the rules. Formalizing processes in defeasible argumentation using. Several books cover the basic theory of logic programming but they focus mostly on the prolog language with its incomplete control strategy and nonlogical features. The proposed methodology is unique in providing a solution for representing incomplete andor contradictory. Grounded consequence for defeasible logic by aldo antonelli. An important feature of the system is that these priorities are not fixed, but are. Read a defeasible logic programming based framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications by naeem khalid janjua available from rakuten kobo.
This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves. In the formalisation of defeasible reasoning, an epistemic diagnosis has largely prevailed according to which some inferences are nonmonotonic because they are provisionally drawn in the absence of relevant or complete information. Logic programming, programming languages, mathematical logic, natural language, what is need, inference, books to buy, computer science, nonfiction logic programming. Defeasible logic programming an argumentative approach. Buy handbook of defeasible reasoning and uncertainty management systems.
Relating defeasible and normal logic programming through. Argument theory change applied to defeasible logic. In logic, defeasible reasoning is a kind of reasoning that is rationally compelling, though not deductively valid. Deploying defeasible logic rule bases for the semantic web. Keywords logic program logic programming description logic business rule ontology language. This handbook was produced inside the sort of earlier handbook assortment identical to the handbook of philosophical logic, the handbook of logic in laptop science, the handbook of logic in artificial intelligence and logic programming, and is perhaps seen as a companion to them in masking the broad functions of logic and reasoning. Programming logic and design, comprehensive pdf ebook php. If youre looking for a free download links of programming logic and design, comprehensive pdf, epub, docx and torrent then this site is not for you. Clocksin shelved 4 times as logic programming avg rating 3. The object language is that of logic programming, complemented with labels that identify distinguished elements for representing knowledge and performing inference.
Regulations are a widespread and important part of government and business. A defeasible logic programmingbased framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications springer theses naeem khalid janjua on. Since dlp is an extension of logic programming, the different types of parallelism studied for logic programming could be applied. Discover the best computer programming logic in best sellers. Defeasiblelogicprogramming anargumentativeapproach. A defeasible logic programming based framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications.
This book reports on the development and validation of a generic defeasible logic programming framework for carrying out. A critical appraisal of karl olivecronas legal philosophy. Defeasible logic is based on the idea of logic programming without negation as failure. Rules and defeasible reasoning on the semantic web. Defeasible logic is a simple but efficient formalism for nonmonotonic reasoning presented, for example, by d. Deontic logic default logic nonmonotonic logic order formula defeasible reasoning these keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. We show that inference in the propositional form of the logic can be performed in linear time.
Lee a defeasible logic programming based framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications por naeem khalid janjua disponible en rakuten kobo. Argumentbased extended logic programming with defeasible. Arguments are expressed in a logic programming language with both weak and strong negation. Proof explanation for the semantic web using defeasible logic. It gives a more rigorous justification of this proposal. Instead, default reasoning is modelled by rules and a priority relation among them. A newspaper story warning that the local water supply has been contaminated would prevent a person from drinking water from the tap in her home. Defeasible logic and its variants are an important family of defeasible reasoning methods.
Handbook of logic in artificial intelligence and logic programming vol. A defeasible logic programmingbased framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications. Wolfgang spohn, defeasible normative reasoning philpapers. Download a defeasible logic programmingbased framework to. Conflicts between arguments are decided with the help of priorities on the rules. In this case, we would do deductions by calculating the probability of the conclusion given the probabilities of the premises. In order to do this, an ldsbased logical framework for defeasible argumentation called lds. On influence and contractions in defeasible logic programming. We will also discuss briey in this paper how to extend delp for considering default negation. In delp, we distinguish between two different sorts of rules.
Theory, practices and challenges logic programming order confirmation email inference political science computer science robotics printers drones economics. Home browse by title books handbook of logic in artificial intelligence and logic programming vol. A in these rules are considered to represent classical negation. A defeasible logic programming based framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications springer theses naeem khalid janjua on. In handbook of logic in artificial intelligence and logic programming, volume 3. The proposed methodology is unique in providing a solution for representing incomplete andor contradictory information coming from different sources, and. A defeasible logic programming based framework to support argumentation in semantic web applications hardcover. Defeasible logic handbook of logic in artificial intelligence and.
Defeasible logic versus logic programming without negation as. Quantified representation of uncertainty and imprecision handbook of defeasible reasoning and uncertainty management systems volume 1 9789048150380. This paper relates the defeasible logic programming delp framework and its semantics sem delp to classical logic programming frameworks. Read adaptive logics for defeasible reasoning applications in argumentation, normative reasoning and default reasoning by christian stra. Deontic logic viewed as defeasible reasoning springerlink. Defeasible reasoning is a simple but efficient approach to nonmonotonic reasoning that has recently attracted considerable interest and that has found various applications. Our results show that the former has a strictly stronger expressive power. The system employs a userfriendly graphical shell and a.
This book describes a semantic webbased approach for addressing the problem of decision making when information is coming from multiple information sources and is incomplete andor contradictory. Defeasible reasoning reasoning with many unknown factors. T here is a lack of accessible yet comprehensive collections of articles covering the key topics in declarative logic programming. The proposed methodology is unique in providing a solution for. This statement would not stand up to rigorous reasoning, because the earth could stop turning or the sun could suddenly explode into a nova. An example of defeasible reasoning would be the statement that the sun will rise tomorrow.
1403 837 1017 248 74 1591 1389 1184 395 1542 1531 1390 1405 495 960 1150 536 754 68 1263 155 875 381 935 1243 1187 37 893 90 680 12 664 1373 1379 1060 328 117 569 902 938